Is Doing Weights and Pilates Considered Overtraining? | Livestrong.com (2024)

Is Doing Weights and Pilates Considered Overtraining? | Livestrong.com (1)

Workouts using light weights are less likely to lead to overtraining.

Image Credit: VichienPetchmai/iStock/GettyImages

Exercise provides good stress for your body. It puts extra demands on your muscular, cardiorespiratory and nervous systems so they grow stronger and more resilient. But too much stress has the opposite effect, notes the American Council on Exercise.

Advertisem*nt

It can leave you with overtraining syndrome, also know as OTS, with symptoms such as poor workout performance, constantly sore muscles, unsatisfying sleep, frequent illness and an overall sense of burnout. What leads to overtraining syndrome is often quite personal. Some people have built up the stamina to tolerate a regular weights and Pilates workout four or more times per week. For someone just getting back to exercise, or starting out, this regimen could burn you out after a month or two.

Video of the Day

Video of the Day

The frequency, intensity and effects of your workouts tell you if you're overtraining. One day of hitting the weight floor and then heading to Pilates class isn't going to push you over the edge, though. Ask yourself the following questions to decide if you need to dial your workouts back a bit.

Tip

Lifting weights and doing Pilates will not generally lead to overtraining, unless you're lifting a lot of weight at a high intensity.

How Intense Are Your Workouts?

When considering whether you're overtraining, ask yourself about the quality and intensity of your workouts. Does "weights" mean lifting 8-pound dumbbells in a class for multiple repetitions to build muscular endurance, or are you doing a full-blown 45-minute session of max lifts on the Olympic platform? The former is unlikely to lead to overtraining, but the latter — when done without intelligently placed rest — just might.

Advertisem*nt

The same is true for your Pilates sessions. A rigorous total-body reformer routine puts more intense stress on the body than a mat-based class that targets important stabilizing muscles. A beginner class will be much milder than an intermediate or advanced class too.

How Often Are Your Workouts?

Pilates and strength training on consecutive days would likely count as overtraining. It may or may not push you into full blown overtraining syndrome, but it is counterproductive. You want to leave at least 48 hours between strength-training sessions, so if you're lifting heavy weights to fatigue, you deserve a day off weights the next day.

Advertisem*nt

Rest is essential to the muscle building process, says the American Council on Exercise. Without it, your muscle fibers can't repair or have the time to grow stronger and thicker. A good approach would be to alternate your Pilates workout days with your weight-training days, then leave at least one day for rest. Therefore, your schedule might look like:

  • Monday: Strength train legs and hips
  • Tuesday: Pilates
  • Wednesday: Upper-body strength training workout
  • Thursday: Pilates
  • Friday: Full-body strength training
  • Saturday: Pilates
  • Sunday: Rest

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt

How Do You Feel?

A big clue as to whether you're doing too much weight training and Pilates is how you feel. If you're chronically sore, it's time to give it a few days off and when you return to training, back off the number of days you do each discipline. If you come to dread your workouts or feel obligated to go, even though you really want a day off, it's another sign you're headed toward workout self-sabotage.

Advertisem*nt

What About Outside the Gym?

Typically, overtraining strikes people who are running, cycling, swimming or doing high-intensity work, such as CrossFit, to an excess. However, any heavy training can leave you feeling overtrained. Irritability, mood swings, fatigue and abnormally high heart rates are symptoms of overtraining. You might also find yourself getting sick more often than usual. Your sleep cycles often get thrown off, so you have trouble sleeping soundly and wake earlier than usual.

Advertisem*nt

Functional Versus Nonfunctional Overtraining

If you're trying to overcome a plateau in your max bench press, or achieve a certain look for an upcoming fitness or bodybuilding competition, you might employ functional overtraining — also referred to as overreaching, according to the Human Performance Resource Center — for a few weeks to achieve your goal.

It might include rigorous weight training and Pilates and, if you kept up this training schedule for several weeks, it could lead you to eventually develop overtraining syndrome. However, when used strategically — perhaps under the auspices of a coach — it can actually lead to gains.

Advertisem*nt

Overtraining usually occurs over time, not all at once. Your body wears down from the stress and once you're in the full-blown syndrome, it's a hard hole to dig out of. So, it's smart to check in often with how you're feeling and your workout progressions. If either start to fail, take a day or two to recoup. Overtraining syndrome can take days or even weeks to resolve.

Advertisem*nt

Advertisem*nt

Is Doing Weights and Pilates Considered Overtraining? | Livestrong.com (2024)

FAQs

Is Doing Weights and Pilates Considered Overtraining? | Livestrong.com? ›

Lifting weights and doing Pilates will not generally lead to overtraining, unless you're lifting a lot of weight at a high intensity.

Is it okay to lift weights and do Pilates? ›

Weightlifting and Pilates are two sides of the same coin. Weightlifting focuses on gaining muscle mass, while Pilates emphasizes muscle lengthening and toning. By combining both exercises, you can experience increased muscle strength and flexibility.

Do you need a rest day from Pilates? ›

Is it like weight training in that you need to rest your muscles for 48 hours between workouts? Pilates is safe enough to do every day. Initially you may want to do it every day so you get a rhythm and become consistent; then a good goal is to do it every other day.

Is Pilates considered strenuous exercise? ›

Intensity level: medium

It's demanding, but not the kind of workout that always works up a sweat. It's all about concentration and breathing.

How much weight training is overtraining? ›

To identify if you're overtraining, you'll need to listen to your body. If you're not able to lift the same weight you did a few weeks ago because you've upped your sessions or you've been doing bench press for a few days in a row, you'll know you're overtraining.

Can you overdo Pilates? ›

Overdoing it on Pilates, especially if you're new to working out in general, can over-stress your muscles, particularly if you don't give them ample recovery time before your next class.

Can I do Pilates and weights on the same day? ›

Like with cardio, you can do Pilates and strength training on different days. Or you can do them on the same day. In the case of the latter, do your weight lifting first, then transition to Pilates. This helps you focus on muscle gain as well as flexibility and all of the other benefits that Pilates has to offer.

Can you stay fit just doing Pilates? ›

Practicing Pilates can be beneficial for your health and help you maintain a healthy weight. Yet, Pilates may not be as effective for weight loss as other cardio exercises, such as running or swimming. That's because you'll burn fewer calories in traditional mat Pilates classes than if you did other cardio exercises.

Is it too much to do Pilates every day? ›

You can absolutely do Pilates every day, however, you will want to be sure to vary the intensity and format of your workout.

How many times a week should I do Pilates to see results? ›

So, how many times a week should you do Pilates? To reap the best benefits, you'll want to do it 3-5 times per week. However, you may not want to do it every day of the week because your muscles need time to recover.

Is Pilates considered cardio or strength training? ›

Pilates is a form of strength training, but it doesn't look like some of the typical strength training exercises you might be familiar with. Pilates focuses more on improving muscle tone than building muscles, but the result is similar: greater stability and endurance.

Can you be too heavy for Pilates? ›

Pilates can easily be adapted to accommodate some of the challenges met by obese individuals. Moreover, a qualified Pilates instructor who has these adaptations at their fingertips will create a welcoming atmosphere for people who are often intimidated by the fitness environment.

What is considered the hardest Pilates workout? ›

The boomerang is considered one of the hardest Pilates exercises, as it requires every muscle in your body to do. How to do it: Sit tall on your mat, legs in front of you, ankles crossed, and hands by your sides. Scoop your belly and round back, lowering yourself onto your mat one vertebra at a time.

What is the best workout routine to avoid overtraining? ›

Avoid overtraining when strength training:
  • Work different muscles each day to allow muscles time to heal and grow.
  • Add 1-3 rest days into your workout routine per week. ...
  • When lifting light weights, you can do more reps. ...
  • Only max out on weights once a week.

What are the symptoms of over exercising? ›

This could lead to physical signs of over-exercising, such as:
  • Frequent injuries when exercising.
  • Constipation, bloating, and cramps in your stomach.
  • Problems with coordination and concentration.
  • Decreased strength.
  • Iron deficiency.
  • Losing lots of weight very quickly.
  • Developing an eating problem.
  • Feeling angry or depressed.

Can you mix Pilates and gym? ›

One popular combination is Pilates and strength training. By incorporating Pilates exercises into a strength training routine, you can improve your overall balance, stability, and flexibility while also building muscle.

Can I build muscle with Pilates? ›

Can You Build Muscle with Pilates? It's possible to strengthen, improve flexibility, and sculpt with Pilates—but as we'll soon see, it's typically not enough on its own to achieve significant muscle gains. At any rate, Pilates helps to maintain muscle since it's a form of resistance training, Aditi notes.

Is Pilates good for weight lifters? ›

The capabilities for core strength often conflict with what the mobility and flexibility in the muscles and joints are able to cope with and sustain during a Pilates session. However, Pilates can help bodybuilders improve their core strength and stability, which will help them maintain control during lifts and poses.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 6288

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.