Fast Tomato Sauce Recipe • The Prairie Homestead (2024)

I spent most of yesterday making tomato sauce.

There was washing, trimming, smashing into a food mill (I have this one and it’s a life saver- affiliate link), simmering, stirring, seasoning, and thennnnnn, finally at 6:39pm, I started ladling the gallons of sauce into quart jars and lowering them into the boiling water canner.

It was a long day.

And I had to ask myself, WHY ON EARTH am I doing this?

No really. I asked myself that.

It was hot, messy, and monotonous. All the components of a super fun day, right?

However, all inconveniences aside, I know it’ll be 100% worth it when I pull those shiny red jars of homegrown tomatoes out of my pantry on a blustery winter day. Not to mention, what else am I going to do with the 5,873 San Marzano tomatoes that are currently in my garden and needing to be canned ASAP?

(P.S. Apparently San Marzanos really like Wyoming.)

Making tomato sauce is a commitment. Long, slow simmering evaporates the water from the tomato puree and results in a thick sauce with an amazing depth of flavor and intensity you just can’t get any other way.

BUT…

Let’s just say you don’t have enough tomatoes to make gallons of sauce to can. And let’s also say that you don’t happen to have 12 hours to patiently watch sauce simmering on the stove.

Well, you still have options, my friends.

I started experimenting with this fast tomato sauce recipe several years ago, and I’ve been making it regularly ever since.It can be whipped up in 15 minutes or less, and only requires a handful of tomatoes, instead of bucketloads. Hallelujah.

The flavor of this quick tomato sauce is different than your traditional all-day tomato sauces (it’s a little brighter and fresher tasting), but it’s quickly becoming my go-to when I need pasta sauce or pizza sauce in a hurry.

I used to have this recipe as a tagalong in my How to Freeze Tomatoes post, but I found myself referencing it so much, I figured it deserved to have updated photos and a post of its very own.

So, here ya go!

How to Make FAST Tomato Sauce (VIDEO)

The FAST Tomato Sauce Recipe

Keep in mind the measurements here are very loose guidelines and definitely not set in stone. I never measure when I’m making tomato sauce, and it’s ALL about the flavor that develops as I put this sauce together. Taste frequently and adjust as needed.

Ingredients:

• 4 cups halved or quartered ripe tomatoes (paste-type tomatoes are the best here, but any variety will do)
• 2 tablespoons extra-virgin olive oil (my favorite olive oil)
• 2 cloves garlic, finely minced
• Salt & pepper, to taste (I use this salt.)
• Fresh basil and/or oregano (optional– dried will work too)

Instructions:

In a medium saucepan, gently heat the garlic in the olive oil for several minutes. We’re not looking to brown it, or even saute it really– just to soften it and mellow out the flavor.

Add in the tomatoes and allow the tomatoes and garlic to mingle, stirring as you go. The tomatoes will release their juices, and you can season with salt/pepper accordingly.

Stir and simmer the tomatoes until softened, and now add in the herbs. You can use dried herbs if you wish, but if at all possible, use fresh basil and/or oregano. The flavor difference is amazing.

Puree the mixture with your hand blender. I like to leave my fresh sauce a little bit on the chunky side.

If you don’t have a hand blender, you can puree in a food processor or blender instead. But seriously– you NEED a hand blender (like this one- affiliate link). I use mineall the time.

Toss with fresh pasta (combining this with homemade pasta is out of this world) or use it as a topping for your favorite pizza recipe.

Remember– this sauce will have a much brighter, fresher flavor than a slow-simmered sauce, or a sauce made with canned tomatoes. Although there’s still a place for all-day-simmered sauce, I adore the brightness of this freshversion.

Tomato Sauce Recipe Notes

• If you have tomatoes in your freezer, this fast tomato sauce recipe is a great place to use ’em! You don’t even have to thaw them first– you can simply pop them straight into the sauce pan after you heat the minced garlic. Allow the tomatoes to thaw out in the pan over medium low heat, and then proceed with the rest of the recipe. And in case you are curious how to freeze tomatoes, here’s my tutorial for that.
• I suppose you could can this sauce if you wanted to, but considering it only makes a small amount, I’m not sure it’d be worth it. I’d recommend sticking to a tomato sauce recipe that’s scaled for water bath canning if you need to use up a lot of tomatoes
• I like to keep this fresh tomato sauce pretty simple and crisp in flavor. However, you can go crazy adding spices and herbs if that’s your jam. Try parsley, crushed red peppers, or even a dash of brown sugar to cut the acidity, if needed.
• This sauce can easily be poured into freezer-safe containers and frozen for several months.

Print

Other Tomato Recipes You’ll Love

• Roasted Poblano Salsa Recipe
• How to Make Sun-Dried Tomatoes
• 40+ Ways to Preserve Tomatoes
• 10 Tips for Growing Tomatoes